| |
Main
Date: 02 Jun 2007 14:16:16
From: RS
Subject: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to order from? thanks
|
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 21:36:52
From: john
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 2, 11:02 pm, RS <r_schil...@comcast.net > wrote: > In article > <mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjn...@comcast.com>, > r_schil...@comcast.net says... > > >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > >order from? thanks > > I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade > 300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all > the input on this. > > Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to > within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or > so? > > thanks Isn't there a "Bearing Engineering" in Emeryville? IIRC it's near the I 80. There is also a pretty good LBS on Telegraph. (I forget the name) I think it's < a block north of University, on both sides of Telegraph. Retail sales on the west nside. Parts & repair on the east side. Good luck, John
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 22:31:13
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"john" <jdrew96@yahoo.com > wrote in message news:1180931812.974260.5160@x35g2000prf.googlegroups.com... > On Jun 2, 11:02 pm, RS <r_schil...@comcast.net> wrote: > > In article > > <mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjn...@comcast.com>, > > r_schil...@comcast.net says... > > > > >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > > >order from? thanks > > > > I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade > > 300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all > > the input on this. > > > > Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to > > within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or > > so? > > > > thanks > > Isn't there a "Bearing Engineering" in Emeryville? IIRC it's near the > I 80. There is also a pretty good LBS on Telegraph. (I forget the > name) I think it's < a block north of University, on both sides of > Telegraph. Retail sales on the west nside. Parts & repair on the east > side. > > Good luck, John > Missing Link on Shatuck. I don't know what they have for sale. Velo Sport moved from MLK to University at California. They only sell loose bearings, not packaged. Chas.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 20:58:16
From: john
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 6:33 pm, A Muzi <a...@yellowjersey.org > wrote: > >>> "bfd" <bfd...@comcast.net> wrote innews:h5SdnV1utJyrefzbnZ2dnUVZ_ompnZ2d@comcast.com: > >>>> Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for > >>>> $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check outwww.biketoolsetc.com > >> sally <s...@sally.com> wrote: > >>> Postage on small items usually kills the price difference vs. your local bike > >>> shop. > > datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >> add:www.loosescrews.com/ > >> Nashbar.com > >> Universalcycles.com > >> one or the other will have a bargain in stock. loose screws are > >> chinese 25's for frequent repacks. > >> Harris Cyclery sells top grade 25's, highly recommended. > john wrote: > > Usually I try to put together an order of $25 to 50 bucks so the > > minimum shipping charge doesn't take quit such a large percentage of > > the total. I prefer buying online for bearings because there is no way > > to know for sure if they are 25 grade. I figure that neither the LBS > > nor the on line supplier is likely to bother to switch lower grades on > > purpose, but it is very easy to accidentally switch them. It seems to > > me that the less they are handled the less chance of mixing. > > > Also the business of not mixing batches of bearings due to different > > diameters. How in Gods name does one know if they are from the same > > batch even if they are in the same bag? I suspect that there are a lot > > of high mileage bike bearings out there that have mixed batches &/ or > > grades. I guess what I'm saying is that I buy gr. 25 batches of > > bearings w/ hope they are more likely to be a matched batch & actually > > gr. 25 bearings. > > > I like BikeToolsEtc due to their location (usually 1 day shipping, UPS > > Ground), > > no sales tax for Calif. & their great customer service. I support Bike > > tools etc. in particular because they provide a much needed connection > > to unusual bike tools & parts @ one location (& 1 shipping charge). I > > also like McMaster-Carr. I could get lost in their on line catalog for > > days. I've never bothered to compare prices. > > You touch on some good questions. I didn't like the answers either years > ago when we changed to our present vendor for American grade 25 > certified chrome steel balls. We don't pay any extra for packaging so we > take them in 25-ball sealed packs. (1/4"; some other sizes in 50pk) > Beats the heck out of trying to maintain a 'purge' routine through the > shop every time we open another sealed kilo of balls and then wonder if > some wiseacre dropped a used bearing in the container. . . > > I believe most vendors sell sealed prepacks now. If some guy is counting > out ball bearings one at a time you are definitely operating on trust. > Which may be well placed. Or not. > -- > Andrew Muziwww.yellowjersey.org > Open every day since 1 April, 1971 Hello Andrew I really like that answer. The next time I need ball bearings, I will definitely order from you. John
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 22:50:49
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 5:26 pm, "* * Chas" <verktygj...@aol.spamski.com > wrote: > "Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote in message > > news:1180907176.079086.253240@p47g2000hsd.googlegroups.com... > > > > > > > On Jun 3, 3:51 pm, SMS <scharf.ste...@geemail.com> wrote: > > > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 > years. > > > > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > > > > around because the grease was so old. > > > > The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease > > > left, and several the bearings had split. > > > > Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a > > > chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. > > > > While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, > > > there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed. > > > There are 'many' cup and cone hubs on the market currently. Many > > people, myself included, prefer them. > > > IMO, sealed cartridge bottom brackets are a decidely 'mixed blessing'. > > I will continue to use C&C BBs on my personal bikes as long as > > possible. > > I recently sent a 20 year old Phil BB back for rebuilding. It was about > 1/2 the price of a new one. That says as much about currency inflation and PW price increases as much as anything. > I'm still riding another Phil BB from the mid > 70s. Mileage? > > Loose bearing setups are rather crude devices dependent upon the quality > and pitch of the threads on the shafts, how well the cups and cones are > ground and so on. > > The tolerance of .0001 between individual balls would be quite large for > better quality sealed ball bearings but is not a big issue for loose ball > arrangements. > > At the rotational speed of ball bearings on a bike, most people could get > by with sleeved bearings and not notice any difference. ;-) > Hmmm.....*ceramic* sleeve bearings; the next big ($) thing! ;-)
|
| | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 07:48:16
From: Michael Press
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
In article <1180911049.149670.19440@p47g2000hsd.googlegroups.com >, Ozark Bicycle <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com > wrote: > On Jun 3, 5:26 pm, "* * Chas" <verktygj...@aol.spamski.com> wrote: [...] > > At the rotational speed of ball bearings on a bike, most people could get > > by with sleeved bearings and not notice any difference. ;-) > > > > Hmmm.....*ceramic* sleeve bearings; the next big ($) thing! ;-) Bronze sleeves bearing a polished cast iron shaft. The perfect match. -- Michael Press
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 20:34:24
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com > wrote in message news:1180911049.149670.19440@p47g2000hsd.googlegroups.com... > On Jun 3, 5:26 pm, "* * Chas" <verktygj...@aol.spamski.com> wrote: > > "Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote in message > > > On Jun 3, 3:51 pm, SMS <scharf.ste...@geemail.com> wrote: > > > > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 > > years. > > > > > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > > > > > around because the grease was so old. > > > > > > The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease > > > > left, and several the bearings had split. > > > > > > Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a > > > > chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. > > > > > > While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, > > > > there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed. > > > > > There are 'many' cup and cone hubs on the market currently. Many > > > people, myself included, prefer them. > > > > > IMO, sealed cartridge bottom brackets are a decidely 'mixed blessing'. > > > I will continue to use C&C BBs on my personal bikes as long as > > > possible. > > > > I recently sent a 20 year old Phil BB back for rebuilding. It was about > > 1/2 the price of a new one. > > That says as much about currency inflation and PW price increases as > much as anything. Repair price was about 1/2 of current new price... > > I'm still riding another Phil BB from the mid 70s. > > Mileage? Yes..... ;-) I don't know any more, about 3 different frames worth. A lot of the use on that BB came when I was riding 200 miles a week (in other words, a long time ago). > > Hmmm.....*ceramic* sleeve bearings; the next big ($) thing! ;-) > Shhhsh! don't get people started. Some derailleur pulleys use ceramic sleeve bearings don't they? Chas.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 21:48:07
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 4:02 pm, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com > wrote: > HOW TO MEASURE BEARING WEAR. > Noooooooooooooooooooo problem! > Compare the used bearings to a an unused bearing of the same batch. Why bother? Just replace 'em during the routine maintenance, IMO. YMMV. > The duller the used bearing, the more out of round it is. > Say, does anyone have the address for the roman stone ball machine > photo?
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 21:46:16
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 3:51 pm, SMS <scharf.ste...@geemail.com > wrote: > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 years. > > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > > around because the grease was so old. > > The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease > left, and several the bearings had split. > > Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a > chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. > > While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, > there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed. There are 'many' cup and cone hubs on the market currently. Many people, myself included, prefer them. IMO, sealed cartridge bottom brackets are a decidely 'mixed blessing'. I will continue to use C&C BBs on my personal bikes as long as possible.
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 15:26:18
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com > wrote in message news:1180907176.079086.253240@p47g2000hsd.googlegroups.com... > On Jun 3, 3:51 pm, SMS <scharf.ste...@geemail.com> wrote: > > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 years. > > > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > > > around because the grease was so old. > > > > The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease > > left, and several the bearings had split. > > > > Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a > > chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. > > > > While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, > > there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed. > > > There are 'many' cup and cone hubs on the market currently. Many > people, myself included, prefer them. > > IMO, sealed cartridge bottom brackets are a decidely 'mixed blessing'. > I will continue to use C&C BBs on my personal bikes as long as > possible. > > I recently sent a 20 year old Phil BB back for rebuilding. It was about 1/2 the price of a new one. I'm still riding another Phil BB from the mid 70s. Loose bearing setups are rather crude devices dependent upon the quality and pitch of the threads on the shafts, how well the cups and cones are ground and so on. The tolerance of .0001 between individual balls would be quite large for better quality sealed ball bearings but is not a big issue for loose ball arrangements. At the rotational speed of ball bearings on a bike, most people could get by with sleeved bearings and not notice any difference. ;-) Chas.
|
| | | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 10:11:16
From: RonSonic
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Sun, 3 Jun 2007 15:26:18 -0700, "* * Chas" <verktygjunk@aol.spamski.com > wrote: > >"Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote in message >news:1180907176.079086.253240@p47g2000hsd.googlegroups.com... >> On Jun 3, 3:51 pm, SMS <scharf.ste...@geemail.com> wrote: >> > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 >years. >> > > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling >> > > around because the grease was so old. >> > >> > The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease >> > left, and several the bearings had split. >> > >> > Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a >> > chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. >> > >> > While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, >> > there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed. >> >> >> There are 'many' cup and cone hubs on the market currently. Many >> people, myself included, prefer them. >> >> IMO, sealed cartridge bottom brackets are a decidely 'mixed blessing'. >> I will continue to use C&C BBs on my personal bikes as long as >> possible. >> >> > >I recently sent a 20 year old Phil BB back for rebuilding. It was about >1/2 the price of a new one. I'm still riding another Phil BB from the mid >70s. > >Loose bearing setups are rather crude devices dependent upon the quality >and pitch of the threads on the shafts, how well the cups and cones are >ground and so on. > >The tolerance of .0001 between individual balls would be quite large for >better quality sealed ball bearings but is not a big issue for loose ball >arrangements. > >At the rotational speed of ball bearings on a bike, most people could get >by with sleeved bearings and not notice any difference. ;-) I use a poured babbit bearing for my bottom bracket! Ron
|
| | | | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 11:57:19
From:
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Mon, 04 Jun 2007 10:11:16 -0400, RonSonic <ronsonic@tampabay.rr.com > wrote: >I use a poured babbit bearing for my bottom bracket! > >Ron Dear Ron, Forget all that spoke-tension nonsense! A hub full of Babbitt metal is the only way (patented!) to secure spokes: http://i17.tinypic.com/53ruw3m.jpg "In constructing the wheel the ends of the spokes are inserted into the perforations of the hub and then the filling is poured in in a molten condition, and adhering to the spokes secures them firmly in place . . . The inner ends of the spokes may be roughened or serrated . . . and these ends may be tinned, if desired, before putting them in place, for the purpose of causing a greater adhesion between the spokes and the [hub] filling; or, if desired, the spokes may be bent . . . as an extra precaution against their working loose in the filling." http://i11.tinypic.com/4m8ldeg.jpg You may wish to adapt my method for preserving the proper tune of stringed instruments. Once the correct note has been achieved, filling the peg-box with Babbitt metal should eliminate the need for any future re-tuning. Cheers, Louis J. Crecelius
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 21:02:59
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
HOW TO MEASURE BEARING WEAR. Noooooooooooooooooooo problem! Compare the used bearings to a an unused bearing of the same batch. The duller the used bearing, the more out of round it is. Say, does anyone have the address for the roman stone ball machine photo?
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 20:12:04
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 2:06 pm, "* * Chas" <verktygj...@aol.spamski.com > wrote: > "Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote in message > > news:1180869997.924057.42920@h2g2000hsg.googlegroups.com... > > > > > > > On Jun 2, 11:00 pm, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com> wrote: > > <snipped> > > > - on bearing ball quality - > > > > at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose > > > Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) > > > Then why comment? > > > > butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to > > > replace these, they look new" > > > Geez, bearing balls are cheap, even the good ones (or, at least, they > > *should* be if you are 'buying smart'); why not replace the balls > > during an overhaul?? You already have the hub/headset/BB open, why > > waste time pinching pennies??? > > > > while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. > > > Typical, IME. > > > <snip> > > > > maybe. > > > the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear > > > number > > > Why speculate when you can know the answer: > > >http://www.steelmedia.com/steel-balls-grades.htm > > > <snip> > > Repacking bike bearings falls somewhat below rearranging my sock drawer on > the desirable activities scale. > > I switched to sealed bearings on a lot of components years ago and never > looked back. > > Campy Record/SR hubs are my one throwback. I love the look and feel of > them. > > I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 years. > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > around because the grease was so old. > > I had an envelope of 7/32" grade 25 chrome steel bearings that was about > 25 years old. I cleaned the hubs and components with solvent and repacked > them with Park grease. After careful adjustment they were rougher feeling > than the old bearings. I checked out some new bearings from the pack with > a 10x magnifier and found organic looking rust trails on the surface. They > looked like tiny brain corals. You fool!! Those were the super secret "Smart Bearings", set to be formally introduced this fall by SRP. Only $5.45 ea. "Smart Bearings - for the not so smart cyclist" * *Copyright 2007 by SRP ;-) > Clean and rebuild a second time with new > bearings.... > > Morale: check the bearing first! > > Chas.- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text -
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 17:28:41
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 12:06 pm, Sheldon Brown <CaptB...@sheldonbrown.com > wrote: > Ozark Bicycle wrote: > > IME, if the bearing balls are routinely replaced during periodic > > maintenance, the 'longevity' of the bearing balls is not an issue. > > Grade 25 means uniform and 'round', making good bearing adjustment a > > snap. For bicycle applications they are, or at least should be, cheap, > > making routine replacement the sensible course of action. > > IME, it just makes sense to replace the bearing balls during an > > overhaul. At $0.05 (or less) each for Grade 25s, why not??? Sure, you > > can pay more and, *maybe* get longer-lived bearing balls, but what's > > the point? Instead of pulling 'em, cleaning 'em and putting 'em back, > > just use new ones. > > Ozark is absolutely right here. I'll add the cleaning issue: it is > most important that everything be clean and as free of grit as > possible. You can look at the cones and cups, with a magnifying glass > if necessary, and verify their condition. You can't reliably do that > with bearing balls, because there's no way to know that you have > actually seen every side of each ball, since they all look the same. > > Also, don't use grease from a tub for this, use grease from a tube or > grease gun, so you know the _grease_ is also clean and un- > contaminated. Tub grease is fine for lubricating screw threads, cable > guides and the like but not for ball bearings. > That last bit, regarding grease, is something easily overlooked, but critical. I'm glad Sheldon mentioned it. Also, if a bearing ball drops to the floor, just dump it, IMO (unless your shop floor is atypically clean!).
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 10:06:37
From: Sheldon Brown
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Ozark Bicycle wrote: > IME, if the bearing balls are routinely replaced during periodic > maintenance, the 'longevity' of the bearing balls is not an issue. > Grade 25 means uniform and 'round', making good bearing adjustment a > snap. For bicycle applications they are, or at least should be, cheap, > making routine replacement the sensible course of action. > IME, it just makes sense to replace the bearing balls during an > overhaul. At $0.05 (or less) each for Grade 25s, why not??? Sure, you > can pay more and, *maybe* get longer-lived bearing balls, but what's > the point? Instead of pulling 'em, cleaning 'em and putting 'em back, > just use new ones. Ozark is absolutely right here. I'll add the cleaning issue: it is most important that everything be clean and as free of grit as possible. You can look at the cones and cups, with a magnifying glass if necessary, and verify their condition. You can't reliably do that with bearing balls, because there's no way to know that you have actually seen every side of each ball, since they all look the same. Also, don't use grease from a tub for this, use grease from a tube or grease gun, so you know the _grease_ is also clean and un- contaminated. Tub grease is fine for lubricating screw threads, cable guides and the like but not for ball bearings. Sheldon "Cleanliness Is Next To..." Brown +----------------------------------------------------+
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 17:00:10
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 11:33 am, jim beam <spamvor...@bad.example.net > wrote: > Ozark Bicycle wrote: > > On Jun 3, 10:34 am, jim beam <spamvor...@bad.example.net> wrote: > >> Ozark Bicycle wrote: > >>> On Jun 3, 9:35 am, still me <wheeled...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >>>> On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle > >>>> <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote: > >>>>>> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or > >>>>>> water/salt seepage? > >>>>> Yep. > >>>> So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what > >>>> Sheldon sells? > >>> You are assuming there *is* a difference. Other than cost, that is not > >>> at all clear. > >> like spokes and their resistance to fatigue being a function of material > >> quality, the same applied to bearings. you can give an inferior > >> material a "grade 25" spherodicity, but it won't last as long as that > >> made of superior material. without testing or metallography, you can't > >> tell the difference - all you can do is perhaps note whether the bearing > >> balls are "ep" or not. if you're cheaping out on material, you'll also > >> presumably be cheap on the extra machining required for that final > >> polish - but it won't be definitive. > > > IME, if the bearing balls are routinely replaced during periodic > > maintenance, the 'longevity' of the bearing balls is not an issue. > > Grade 25 means uniform and 'round', making good bearing adjustment a > > snap. For bicycle applications they are, or at least should be, cheap, > > making routine replacement the sensible course of action. > > >>>> I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but > >>>> the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think > >>>> that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings > >>>> are always going to outlast the race. > >>>> Not pinching pennies, just curious. > >>> IMO, buy Grade 25 bearing balls (for their uniformity and 'roundness') > >>> and replace the balls when you overhaul the component. Grit is a great > >>> cause of wear; thoughly removing grit means removing the bearing balls > >>> and cleaning everything. Why not just replace the bearing balls at > >>> that point? > >> it may be "nice", but as far as the races are concerned, the components > >> that really determine life in bike bearings, it's pretty much a > >> pointless exercise - won't make the slightest difference to whether they > >> spall. > > > IME, it just makes sense to replace the bearing balls during an > > overhaul. At $0.05 (or less) each for Grade 25s, why not??? Sure, you > > can pay more and, *maybe* get longer-lived bearing balls, but what's > > the point? Instead of pulling 'em, cleaning 'em and putting 'em back, > > just use new ones. > > feel free to do it! it's cheap and may save a little time in cleanup. Which is part of the point. > > i'm simply saying that from an engineering perspective, it's pointless. > if the same logic were applied to frames, we'd replace them every 6 > months in case of fatigue. but we don't do it because they're expensive > and we can see cracking with a naked eye. bearing ball replacement is > little more than "feelgood" in the absence of replacement of other > bearing elements also - with no visual feedback, we attribute other > presumed benefits The molehills are getting bigger here. My point, quite simply, is a recommendation to use Grade 25 bearing balls for their uniformity and 'roundness', replacing them routinely and *not sweating* the bearing ball hardness/polish/etc. issues. Like effective grease, good quality bearing balls are a cheap commodity. -30-
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 16:52:18
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
future projections and averages divided by murphy's law governs. 200s/300s wear the cones 25 rocket science chromium does not. so go cheap-replace cones go a couple bucks more for the topend 25s and save yourself time and labor unless murphy's law intervenes-which it does right? but averaging on the long run IF you run long the expensive metal standard not racing asphlat bike component is the best deal I ahve an exception: pedals. buying inexpensive pedal then maintaining is two for one on the next $$$ level up. but it diesn't look like your getting more mileage tho slightly less overall friction from the $$$ pedals.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 16:19:28
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 10:34 am, jim beam <spamvor...@bad.example.net > wrote: > Ozark Bicycle wrote: > > On Jun 3, 9:35 am, still me <wheeled...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >> On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle > > >> <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote: > >>>> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or > >>>> water/salt seepage? > >>> Yep. > >> So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what > >> Sheldon sells? > > > You are assuming there *is* a difference. Other than cost, that is not > > at all clear. > > like spokes and their resistance to fatigue being a function of material > quality, the same applied to bearings. you can give an inferior > material a "grade 25" spherodicity, but it won't last as long as that > made of superior material. without testing or metallography, you can't > tell the difference - all you can do is perhaps note whether the bearing > balls are "ep" or not. if you're cheaping out on material, you'll also > presumably be cheap on the extra machining required for that final > polish - but it won't be definitive. IME, if the bearing balls are routinely replaced during periodic maintenance, the 'longevity' of the bearing balls is not an issue. Grade 25 means uniform and 'round', making good bearing adjustment a snap. For bicycle applications they are, or at least should be, cheap, making routine replacement the sensible course of action. > > > > >> I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but > >> the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think > >> that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings > >> are always going to outlast the race. > > >> Not pinching pennies, just curious. > > > IMO, buy Grade 25 bearing balls (for their uniformity and 'roundness') > > and replace the balls when you overhaul the component. Grit is a great > > cause of wear; thoughly removing grit means removing the bearing balls > > and cleaning everything. Why not just replace the bearing balls at > > that point? > > it may be "nice", but as far as the races are concerned, the components > that really determine life in bike bearings, it's pretty much a > pointless exercise - won't make the slightest difference to whether they > spall. IME, it just makes sense to replace the bearing balls during an overhaul. At $0.05 (or less) each for Grade 25s, why not??? Sure, you can pay more and, *maybe* get longer-lived bearing balls, but what's the point? Instead of pulling 'em, cleaning 'em and putting 'em back, just use new ones.
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 09:33:53
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Ozark Bicycle wrote: > On Jun 3, 10:34 am, jim beam <spamvor...@bad.example.net> wrote: >> Ozark Bicycle wrote: >>> On Jun 3, 9:35 am, still me <wheeled...@yahoo.com> wrote: >>>> On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle >>>> <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote: >>>>>> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or >>>>>> water/salt seepage? >>>>> Yep. >>>> So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what >>>> Sheldon sells? >>> You are assuming there *is* a difference. Other than cost, that is not >>> at all clear. >> like spokes and their resistance to fatigue being a function of material >> quality, the same applied to bearings. you can give an inferior >> material a "grade 25" spherodicity, but it won't last as long as that >> made of superior material. without testing or metallography, you can't >> tell the difference - all you can do is perhaps note whether the bearing >> balls are "ep" or not. if you're cheaping out on material, you'll also >> presumably be cheap on the extra machining required for that final >> polish - but it won't be definitive. > > IME, if the bearing balls are routinely replaced during periodic > maintenance, the 'longevity' of the bearing balls is not an issue. > Grade 25 means uniform and 'round', making good bearing adjustment a > snap. For bicycle applications they are, or at least should be, cheap, > making routine replacement the sensible course of action. >> >> >>>> I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but >>>> the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think >>>> that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings >>>> are always going to outlast the race. >>>> Not pinching pennies, just curious. >>> IMO, buy Grade 25 bearing balls (for their uniformity and 'roundness') >>> and replace the balls when you overhaul the component. Grit is a great >>> cause of wear; thoughly removing grit means removing the bearing balls >>> and cleaning everything. Why not just replace the bearing balls at >>> that point? >> it may be "nice", but as far as the races are concerned, the components >> that really determine life in bike bearings, it's pretty much a >> pointless exercise - won't make the slightest difference to whether they >> spall. > > IME, it just makes sense to replace the bearing balls during an > overhaul. At $0.05 (or less) each for Grade 25s, why not??? Sure, you > can pay more and, *maybe* get longer-lived bearing balls, but what's > the point? Instead of pulling 'em, cleaning 'em and putting 'em back, > just use new ones. > > feel free to do it! it's cheap and may save a little time in cleanup. i'm simply saying that from an engineering perspective, it's pointless. if the same logic were applied to frames, we'd replace them every 6 months in case of fatigue. but we don't do it because they're expensive and we can see cracking with a naked eye. bearing ball replacement is little more than "feelgood" in the absence of replacement of other bearing elements also - with no visual feedback, we attribute other presumed benefits.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 15:27:52
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
> Not pinching pennies, just curious. well, i'm not an engineer like beam but i take it apart and put it abck together X times. with shimano equipment, wood or fl grease, and harris 25 rocket science bearings coupled with a 'normal' preventive maintenance schedule: rear hub goes 2 bearing replacements per cone then the hub is worn out after the second cone so 3 bearing repacks. HD commuting/touring- shopping at 60-70 pounds rear rack. the ritchey headset is 4 repacks new bearings-no visual wear on the crown race original BB's Harris 25's 5 repacks and worn out-15K miles? P. wood and finish line cycle grease with walmart castrol marine grease when the cones get rough. I don't see any reason for cone replacement before at least 2 repacks. is there friction gain over the repacks and no cone? not noticeable compared to installing a caged bearing set after loose bearings. i gotta go rebuild the rear wheel with a new deore XT following an attack from THE FRIENDS OF LEMOND.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 15:26:37
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 8:50 am, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com > wrote: <snipped? - more on bearing balls and maintenence - > 300's will do it. with wood or finish line teflon [grease] at Florida temps, > occasional rain, the grease absolves and washes out so that after a > year its shot and into a grinding compound downward spiral. Geez, this seems bass ackward; why use cheap (less uniform and less 'round') bearing balls and overpriced designer grease??? What do you think has a tougher duty cycle, a bicycle hub bearing or a boat trailer wheel bearing? IME, marine grease, packed and priced like the commodity that grease really is, is ideal for use in bicycle bearings. > Which is the problem, I'm told: dirt. This is exactly why it makes sense to replace the bearing balls whilst overhauling the component. A through cleaning means removing the bearing balls anyway; instead of cleaning 'em, just replace 'em.
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 08:49:52
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Ozark Bicycle wrote: > On Jun 3, 8:50 am, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com> wrote: > > <snipped? > > - more on bearing balls and maintenence - > >> 300's will do it. with wood or finish line teflon [grease] at Florida temps, >> occasional rain, the grease absolves and washes out so that after a >> year its shot and into a grinding compound downward spiral. > > > Geez, this seems bass ackward; why use cheap (less uniform and less > 'round') bearing balls and overpriced designer grease??? > > What do you think has a tougher duty cycle, a bicycle hub bearing or a > boat trailer wheel bearing? IME, marine grease, packed and priced like > the commodity that grease really is, is ideal for use in bicycle > bearings. indeed. marine grease is ideal for bikes - the moisture resistance does make a difference to bearing life. > > >> Which is the problem, I'm told: dirt. > > This is exactly why it makes sense to replace the bearing balls whilst > overhauling the component. A through cleaning means removing the > bearing balls anyway; instead of cleaning 'em, just replace 'em. there's some truth in that. but the best solution is high quality sealed bearings. headsets, hubs, bb's - in each instance where i have high quality sealed bearings, i've had zero maintenance issues. avoid cheapo "low drag" bearings sold for bike applications - their seals are useless and bearing life is compromised accordingly.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 15:15:31
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 9:35 am, still me <wheeled...@yahoo.com > wrote: > On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle > > <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote: > >> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or > >> water/salt seepage? > > >Yep. > > So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what > Sheldon sells? You are assuming there *is* a difference. Other than cost, that is not at all clear. > I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but > the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think > that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings > are always going to outlast the race. > > Not pinching pennies, just curious. IMO, buy Grade 25 bearing balls (for their uniformity and 'roundness') and replace the balls when you overhaul the component. Grit is a great cause of wear; thoughly removing grit means removing the bearing balls and cleaning everything. Why not just replace the bearing balls at that point?
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 08:34:11
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Ozark Bicycle wrote: > On Jun 3, 9:35 am, still me <wheeled...@yahoo.com> wrote: >> On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle >> >> <bicycleatel...@ozarkbicycleservice.com> wrote: >>>> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or >>>> water/salt seepage? >>> Yep. >> So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what >> Sheldon sells? > > You are assuming there *is* a difference. Other than cost, that is not > at all clear. like spokes and their resistance to fatigue being a function of material quality, the same applied to bearings. you can give an inferior material a "grade 25" spherodicity, but it won't last as long as that made of superior material. without testing or metallography, you can't tell the difference - all you can do is perhaps note whether the bearing balls are "ep" or not. if you're cheaping out on material, you'll also presumably be cheap on the extra machining required for that final polish - but it won't be definitive. > > >> I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but >> the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think >> that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings >> are always going to outlast the race. >> >> Not pinching pennies, just curious. > > IMO, buy Grade 25 bearing balls (for their uniformity and 'roundness') > and replace the balls when you overhaul the component. Grit is a great > cause of wear; thoughly removing grit means removing the bearing balls > and cleaning everything. Why not just replace the bearing balls at > that point? it may be "nice", but as far as the races are concerned, the components that really determine life in bike bearings, it's pretty much a pointless exercise - won't make the slightest difference to whether they spall.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 13:50:29
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
rs- track the maintenance with a log and repack in a year or two which ever is convient. 300's will do it. with wood or finish line teflon at Florida temps, occasional rain, the grease absolves and washes out so that after a year its shot and into a grinding compound downward spiral. Which is the problem, I'm told: dirt. Beam sez spalling but the degrading takes place on a microscopic level with the metal getting ground off not lubed with clean grease. so if the bearing lacks ultimate rocket science chromium content hardness like the 300's, the bearing goes out of round to ellipsoid and instead of rolling, begins slamming around in there like a hammer pounding the grinding compound, and less of it every day, into the cone. bummer! by the way, finish line teflon 'seams' to have an edge on procrastin nation repacks with some impressive lube power at very low film quantities. that's a good link but it doesn't tell you what you're buying. i can't compare caws I went to cartridge BB, haven't redone the asian 25 bearing headset with low chromium content nor the deore rear hub. inbetween. I'll get back to you on it. I'll shout from the bypass!
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 10:16:26
From: RS
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
In article <1180878629.289665.209300@w5g2000hsg.googlegroups.com >, datakoll@yahoo.com says... > > >rs- >track the maintenance with a log and repack in a year or two which >ever is convient. >300's will do it. with wood or finish line teflon at Florida temps, >occasional rain, the grease absolves and washes out so that after a >year its shot and into a grinding compound downward spiral. >Which is the problem, I'm told: dirt. >Beam sez spalling but the degrading takes place on a microscopic level >with the metal getting ground off not lubed with clean grease. >so if the bearing lacks ultimate rocket science chromium content >hardness like the 300's, the bearing goes out of round to ellipsoid >and instead of rolling, begins slamming around in there like a hammer >pounding the grinding compound, and less of it every day, into the >cone. bummer! >by the way, finish line teflon 'seams' to have an edge on procrastin >nation repacks with some impressive lube power at very low film >quantities. >that's a good link but it doesn't tell you what you're buying. >i can't compare caws I went to cartridge BB, haven't redone the asian >25 bearing headset with low chromium content nor the deore rear hub. >inbetween. I'll get back to you on it. I'll shout from the bypass! > > > > > > > Thanks!
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 3, 1:29 am, "Phil, Non-Squid" <n...@try.to > wrote: > jim beam wrote: > > datakoll wrote: > >> rei bearings! amazing. > >> we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a grade > >> 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price ranges > >> are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. > >> the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the > >> prices!! > >> the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl > >> have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty > >> racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's > >> at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose > >> Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) > >> butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to > >> replace these, they look new" > >> while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. > >> If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if > >> you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing the > >> bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings will > >> pay off. > >> On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent > >> replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line > >> cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are > >> softer than the 25's. maybe. > >> the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear > >> number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon > >> steel at much lower price. > >> which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the > >> air without getting a degree in bearing science. > >> get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then > >> inspect with magnifier and bright lught? > > > bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is > > related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing > > balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a > > visible difference you can seek for comparison. > > Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or > water/salt seepage? > Yep.
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 14:35:21
From: still me
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Sun, 03 Jun 2007 11:29:12 -0000, Ozark Bicycle <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com > wrote: >> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or >> water/salt seepage? >> > >Yep. So does it make much difference whether we use Asian bearings or what Sheldon sells? I can't make microscopic measurements on bearings, but the races/cones (when failed) are "naked eye" failures. I would think that the bearings are so much harder than the races that the bearings are always going to outlast the race. Not pinching pennies, just curious.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 11:26:37
From: Ozark Bicycle
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 2, 11:00 pm, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com > wrote: <snipped > - on bearing ball quality - > at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose > Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) Then why comment? > butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to > replace these, they look new" Geez, bearing balls are cheap, even the good ones (or, at least, they *should* be if you are 'buying smart'); why not replace the balls during an overhaul?? You already have the hub/headset/BB open, why waste time pinching pennies??? > while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. Typical, IME. <snip > > maybe. > the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear > number Why speculate when you can know the answer: http://www.steelmedia.com/steel-balls-grades.htm <snip >
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 12:06:09
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"Ozark Bicycle" <bicycleatelier@ozarkbicycleservice.com > wrote in message news:1180869997.924057.42920@h2g2000hsg.googlegroups.com... > On Jun 2, 11:00 pm, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com> wrote: > <snipped> > > - on bearing ball quality - > > > at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose > > Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) > > Then why comment? > > > > > butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to > > replace these, they look new" > > > Geez, bearing balls are cheap, even the good ones (or, at least, they > *should* be if you are 'buying smart'); why not replace the balls > during an overhaul?? You already have the hub/headset/BB open, why > waste time pinching pennies??? > > > > while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. > > Typical, IME. > > <snip> > > > maybe. > > the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear > > number > > Why speculate when you can know the answer: > > http://www.steelmedia.com/steel-balls-grades.htm > > > <snip> Repacking bike bearings falls somewhat below rearranging my sock drawer on the desirable activities scale. I switched to sealed bearings on a lot of components years ago and never looked back. Campy Record/SR hubs are my one throwback. I love the look and feel of them. I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 years. They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling around because the grease was so old. I had an envelope of 7/32" grade 25 chrome steel bearings that was about 25 years old. I cleaned the hubs and components with solvent and repacked them with Park grease. After careful adjustment they were rougher feeling than the old bearings. I checked out some new bearings from the pack with a 10x magnifier and found organic looking rust trails on the surface. They looked like tiny brain corals. Clean and rebuild a second time with new bearings.... Morale: check the bearing first! Chas.
|
| | | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 13:51:09
From: SMS
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
> I had several front wheels that hadn't been repacked in at least 10 years. > They ran really smooth but I could hear the bearings loosely rolling > around because the grease was so old. The wheel I did yesterday wasn't running smooth. There was no grease left, and several the bearings had split. Unfortunately, I did use grease from a new tub, applied with a chopstick. I'll do the tube thing next time. While no one would ever buy a bike these days without sealed bearings, there are still a lot of older classics around that aren't sealed.
|
| |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 23:02:16
From: RS
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
In article <mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com >, r_schiller@comcast.net says... > > >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to >order from? thanks > I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade 300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all the input on this. Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or so? thanks
|
| | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 10:13:07
From: RonSonic
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Sat, 02 Jun 2007 23:02:16 -0700, RS <r_schiller@comcast.net > wrote: >In article ><mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com>, >r_schiller@comcast.net says... >> >> >>I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to >>order from? thanks >> >I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade >300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all >the input on this. > >Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to >within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or >so? I'm sure of it, but live on the other side of the country so don't know who they are. Hit the phone book. Almost any city with any amount of industry has bearing suppy houses. Ron
|
| | | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 09:11:52
From: Tom Nakashima
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Here is the Company I use: http://www.precisionballs.com/ -tom
|
| | | | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 20:55:01
From: RS
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
In article <f41dk8$duu$1@news.Stanford.EDU >, tom@slac.stanford.edu says... > > >Here is the Company I use: >http://www.precisionballs.com/ >-tom > > Which specific product from them? They have many and I would need 1/4" Grade 25 or equivelent, they have many types so which is best? thanks
|
| | | | | |
Date: 05 Jun 2007 06:50:25
From: Tom Nakashima
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"RS" <r_schiller@comcast.net > wrote in message news:o9udnbKXTrEEQ_nbnZ2dnUVZ_sfinZ2d@comcast.com... > In article <f41dk8$duu$1@news.Stanford.EDU>, > tom@slac.stanford.edu says... >> >> >>Here is the Company I use: >>http://www.precisionballs.com/ >>-tom >> >> > Which specific product from them? They have many and I would need > 1/4" Grade 25 or equivelent, they have many types so which is best? > > thanks > You can mix and match size to fill a minimum order...that said, I use the 1/4" grade 25 ball bearings the most since they're for the bottom bracket area. The other size I order is for the Wheel bearings. If you can call Bal Tec to place the order, they are more than willing to help. The min. order is inexpensive. $15.oo and you probably have a life-time supply. Here is their phone number (1-800-322-5832) good luck, -tom
|
| | | | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 09:46:31
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"Tom Nakashima" <tom@slac.stanford.edu > wrote in message news:f41dk8$duu$1@news.Stanford.EDU... > Here is the Company I use: > http://www.precisionballs.com/ > -tom > > I've used them for ball sizing and ball measuring balls - "They have big balls". ;-) Chas.
|
| | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 07:50:44
From: Michael Press
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
In article <mKKdnVnUMor0xP_bnZ2dnUVZ_sninZ2d@comcast.com >, RS <r_schiller@comcast.net > wrote: > In article > <mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com>, > r_schiller@comcast.net says... > > > > > >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > >order from? thanks > > > I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade > 300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all > the input on this. > > Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to > within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or > so? Pull out your yellow pages tomorrow. I expect you will find exactly what you seek. -- Michael Press
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 11:44:56
From: * * Chas
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"RS" <r_schiller@comcast.net > wrote in message news:mKKdnVnUMor0xP_bnZ2dnUVZ_sninZ2d@comcast.com... > In article > <mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com>, > r_schiller@comcast.net says... > > > > > >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > >order from? thanks > > > I need bearings from time to time, not a lot. One local shop had grade > 300 and I wanted 25, it is normally a very good shop. I appreciate all > the input on this. > > Here's a long shot, any industrial supply houses I can just go ride to > within 20-30 miles of Oakland, California that has a bottle of 100 or > so? > > thanks > Check the yellow pages: Bearing Engineering has stores in Emeryville and San Leandro, Kaman has a store in San Leandro too. Also, you can check with Grainger, they have several outlets. Bearing supply companies used to sell loose bearings in 100 pack paper envelopes that were treated with a rust preventative, also 1000 pack cardboard boxes. Loose bearings in plastic condiment bottles may be coming from wholesale bike parts distributors. Several LBSs gave me dumb or dirty looks when I asked about buying bearings by the bottle. Good luck, Chas.
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 04:00:59
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
rei bearings! amazing. we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a grade 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price ranges are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the prices!! the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to replace these, they look new" while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing the bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings will pay off. On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are softer than the 25's. maybe. the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon steel at much lower price. which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the air without getting a degree in bearing science. get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then inspect with magnifier and bright lught?
|
| | |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 21:55:52
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
datakoll wrote: > rei bearings! amazing. > we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a grade > 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price ranges > are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. > the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the > prices!! > the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl have > a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty racing/touring > or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's > at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose > Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) > butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to > replace these, they look new" > while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. > If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if > you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing the > bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings will pay > off. > On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent replacement > of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line cycle lube > could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are softer than > the 25's. maybe. > the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear > number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon > steel at much lower price. > which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the air > without getting a degree in bearing science. > get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then > inspect with magnifier and bright lught? > bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a visible difference you can seek for comparison.
|
| | | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 02:29:28
From: Phil, Non-Squid
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
jim beam wrote: > datakoll wrote: >> rei bearings! amazing. >> we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a grade >> 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price ranges >> are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. >> the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the >> prices!! >> the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl >> have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty >> racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's >> at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose >> Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) >> butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to >> replace these, they look new" >> while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. >> If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if >> you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing the >> bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings will >> pay off. >> On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent >> replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line >> cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are >> softer than the 25's. maybe. >> the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear >> number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon >> steel at much lower price. >> which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the >> air without getting a degree in bearing science. >> get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then >> inspect with magnifier and bright lught? >> > > bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is > related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing > balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a > visible difference you can seek for comparison. Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or water/salt seepage? -- Phil
|
| | | | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 07:31:09
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Phil, Non-Squid wrote: > jim beam wrote: >> datakoll wrote: >>> rei bearings! amazing. >>> we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a grade >>> 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price ranges >>> are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. >>> the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the >>> prices!! >>> the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl >>> have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty >>> racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's >>> at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose >>> Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) >>> butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to >>> replace these, they look new" >>> while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. >>> If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if >>> you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing the >>> bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings will >>> pay off. >>> On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent >>> replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line >>> cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are >>> softer than the 25's. maybe. >>> the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear >>> number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon >>> steel at much lower price. >>> which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the >>> air without getting a degree in bearing science. >>> get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then >>> inspect with magnifier and bright lught? >>> >> bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is >> related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing >> balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a >> visible difference you can seek for comparison. > > Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or > water/salt seepage? > it's not usually lack of lubrication, but they do indeed fail first. replacing bearing balls is a pointless exercise if the cones are not replaced first. water seepage/grit intrusion is another issue and will destroy any bearing, regardless of quality.
|
| | | | | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 12:04:46
From: Phil, Non-Squid
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
jim beam wrote: > Phil, Non-Squid wrote: >> jim beam wrote: >>> datakoll wrote: >>>> rei bearings! amazing. >>>> we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a >>>> grade 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price >>>> ranges are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. >>>> the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the >>>> prices!! >>>> the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl >>>> have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty >>>> racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's >>>> at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose >>>> Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) >>>> butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to >>>> replace these, they look new" >>>> while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. >>>> If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if >>>> you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing >>>> the bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings >>>> will pay off. >>>> On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent >>>> replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line >>>> cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are >>>> softer than the 25's. maybe. >>>> the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear >>>> number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon >>>> steel at much lower price. >>>> which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the >>>> air without getting a degree in bearing science. >>>> get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then >>>> inspect with magnifier and bright lught? >>>> >>> bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is >>> related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing >>> balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a >>> visible difference you can seek for comparison. >> >> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or >> water/salt seepage? >> > it's not usually lack of lubrication, but they do indeed fail first. > replacing bearing balls is a pointless exercise if the cones are not > replaced first. I neglected to mention that headsets were the subject in my mind when I wrote that hence the lack of lubrication comment (sweaty roadies in particular vs. MTBers). -- Phil
|
| | | | | | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 09:10:31
From: jim beam
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
Phil, Non-Squid wrote: > jim beam wrote: >> Phil, Non-Squid wrote: >>> jim beam wrote: >>>> datakoll wrote: >>>>> rei bearings! amazing. >>>>> we spoke on bearings several times with experience suggesting a >>>>> grade 25 bearing was a duh 25 bearing. Visually 25s i n wide price >>>>> ranges are shiny and shinier like 8 then 10. >>>>> the loose screws 25 bearings are probably rei bearings-check the >>>>> prices!! >>>>> the harris bearings are rocket science bearings for BB ( ifn yawl >>>>> have a balla and cone) or HD rear hub for HD commuting/mitty >>>>> racing/touring or just for fun if you're into spending RSB's >>>>> at this time I have no way to compare the Harris 25 to the Loose >>>>> Screws 25 (maybe the bikepartsetc also-its a coastal port thing) >>>>> butbutbut each disassembly of the harris bearings was "do I need to >>>>> replace these, they look new" >>>>> while the cones (Shimano and Wheels) were degrading. >>>>> If the assembly is generic at $10-20 go for the asian 25s but if >>>>> you're repacking a $50+ assembly or in a headset where replacing >>>>> the bearing surfaces is a hassle then the rocket science bearings >>>>> will pay off. >>>>> On the other hand, just to screw you around here, frequent >>>>> replacement of 200 carbon steel bearings with woods or finish line >>>>> cycle lube could be easier on the bearing surfaces as the 200's are >>>>> softer than the 25's. maybe. >>>>> the 25 is a sphericity number for roundness not a hardness or wear >>>>> number so a 25 could be carbon steel but rounder than a 200 carbon >>>>> steel at much lower price. >>>>> which is a good reason to spend the extra dough for RSB-clears the >>>>> air without getting a degree in bearing science. >>>>> get sevral kinds and put them in the vise grips and file twice then >>>>> inspect with magnifier and bright lught? >>>>> >>>> bearings more usually fail by spalling, and that's fatigue. that is >>>> related to high quality surface finish. "ep" [extra polish] bearing >>>> balls, can have a much better life span because of it - that's a >>>> visible difference you can seek for comparison. >>> Don't the races/cones die first usually from lack of lubrication or >>> water/salt seepage? >>> >> it's not usually lack of lubrication, but they do indeed fail first. >> replacing bearing balls is a pointless exercise if the cones are not >> replaced first. > > I neglected to mention that headsets were the subject in my mind when I > wrote that hence the lack of lubrication comment (sweaty roadies in > particular vs. MTBers). > marine grease, or better yet, sealed bearings.
|
| |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 20:17:56
From: SMS
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
RS wrote: > I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > order from? thanks Wow, what a coincidence, I needed the same bearings today. I went to REI and they sold them to me for 15¢ each. I don't know if they were grade 25 or not, but I suspect that they were. Loose Screws is a good on-line source for that sort of thing. I often order stuff from McMaster, and they have them too, as someone else pointed out, 100 for $4.12 which is a good price. Most bike shops will have these and will sell them to you.
|
| |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 19:47:49
From: john
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 2, 6:20 pm, datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com > wrote: > On Jun 2, 8:55 pm, sally <s...@sally.com> wrote: > > > "bfd" <bfd...@comcast.net> wrote innews:h5SdnV1utJyrefzbnZ2dnUVZ_ompnZ2d@comcast.com: > > > > Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for > > > $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check outwww.biketoolsetc.com > > > Postage on small items usually kills the price difference vs. your local bike > > shop. > > add:www.loosescrews.com/ > Nashbar.com > Universalcycles.com > one or the other will have a bargain in stock. loose screws are > chinese 25's for frequent repacks. > Harris Cyclery sells top grade 25's, highly recommended. Usually I try to put together an order of $25 to 50 bucks so the minimum shipping charge doesn't take quit such a large percentage of the total. I prefer buying online for bearings because there is no way to know for sure if they are 25 grade. I figure that neither the LBS nor the on line supplier is likely to bother to switch lower grades on purpose, but it is very easy to accidentally switch them. It seems to me that the less they are handled the less chance of mixing. Also the business of not mixing batches of bearings due to different diameters. How in Gods name does one know if they are from the same batch even if they are in the same bag? I suspect that there are a lot of high mileage bike bearings out there that have mixed batches &/ or grades. I guess what I'm saying is that I buy gr. 25 batches of bearings w/ hope they are more likely to be a matched batch & actually gr. 25 bearings. I like BikeToolsEtc due to their location (usually 1 day shipping, UPS Ground), no sales tax for Calif. & their great customer service. I support Bike tools etc. in particular because they provide a much needed connection to unusual bike tools & parts @ one location (& 1 shipping charge). I also like McMaster-Carr. I could get lost in their on line catalog for days. I've never bothered to compare prices. Regards, John
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 20:33:26
From: A Muzi
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
>>> "bfd" <bfd...@comcast.net> wrote innews:h5SdnV1utJyrefzbnZ2dnUVZ_ompnZ2d@comcast.com: >>>> Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for >>>> $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check outwww.biketoolsetc.com >> sally <s...@sally.com> wrote: >>> Postage on small items usually kills the price difference vs. your local bike >>> shop. > datakoll <datak...@yahoo.com> wrote: >> add:www.loosescrews.com/ >> Nashbar.com >> Universalcycles.com >> one or the other will have a bargain in stock. loose screws are >> chinese 25's for frequent repacks. >> Harris Cyclery sells top grade 25's, highly recommended. john wrote: > Usually I try to put together an order of $25 to 50 bucks so the > minimum shipping charge doesn't take quit such a large percentage of > the total. I prefer buying online for bearings because there is no way > to know for sure if they are 25 grade. I figure that neither the LBS > nor the on line supplier is likely to bother to switch lower grades on > purpose, but it is very easy to accidentally switch them. It seems to > me that the less they are handled the less chance of mixing. > > Also the business of not mixing batches of bearings due to different > diameters. How in Gods name does one know if they are from the same > batch even if they are in the same bag? I suspect that there are a lot > of high mileage bike bearings out there that have mixed batches &/ or > grades. I guess what I'm saying is that I buy gr. 25 batches of > bearings w/ hope they are more likely to be a matched batch & actually > gr. 25 bearings. > > I like BikeToolsEtc due to their location (usually 1 day shipping, UPS > Ground), > no sales tax for Calif. & their great customer service. I support Bike > tools etc. in particular because they provide a much needed connection > to unusual bike tools & parts @ one location (& 1 shipping charge). I > also like McMaster-Carr. I could get lost in their on line catalog for > days. I've never bothered to compare prices. You touch on some good questions. I didn't like the answers either years ago when we changed to our present vendor for American grade 25 certified chrome steel balls. We don't pay any extra for packaging so we take them in 25-ball sealed packs. (1/4"; some other sizes in 50pk) Beats the heck out of trying to maintain a 'purge' routine through the shop every time we open another sealed kilo of balls and then wonder if some wiseacre dropped a used bearing in the container. . . I believe most vendors sell sealed prepacks now. If some guy is counting out ball bearings one at a time you are definitely operating on trust. Which may be well placed. Or not. -- Andrew Muzi www.yellowjersey.org Open every day since 1 April, 1971
|
| |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 01:20:39
From: datakoll
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 2, 8:55 pm, sally <s...@sally.com > wrote: > "bfd" <bfd...@comcast.net> wrote innews:h5SdnV1utJyrefzbnZ2dnUVZ_ompnZ2d@comcast.com: > > > Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for > > $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check outwww.biketoolsetc.com > > Postage on small items usually kills the price difference vs. your local bike > shop. add: www.loosescrews.com/ Nashbar.com Universalcycles.com one or the other will have a bargain in stock. loose screws are chinese 25's for frequent repacks. Harris Cyclery sells top grade 25's, highly recommended.
|
| |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 14:42:18
From: bfd
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"RS" <r_schiller@comcast.net > wrote in message news:mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com... >I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > order from? thanks > Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check out www.biketoolsetc.com Good Luck!
|
| | |
Date: 04 Jun 2007 10:00:31
From: RonSonic
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Sat, 2 Jun 2007 14:42:18 -0700, "bfd" <bfd853@comcast.net > wrote: > >"RS" <r_schiller@comcast.net> wrote in message >news:mMudnWmFQNGHQ_zbnZ2dnUVZ_rSjnZ2d@comcast.com... >>I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to >> order from? thanks >> >Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for $0.05 >each! If you must mail order, check out www.biketoolsetc.com The yuppie trap L - BS near me sells grade 200 in packs of 20 (yes, twenty) for $3.95. Of course these are the same jack holes who said that they don't carry rear der hanger bolts without the hanger, "bring in the bike and we'll order you one." Anyway, the point was, go to the real bike shop, not the one with the huge brightly lit sales floor. Ron
|
| | |
Date: 03 Jun 2007 00:55:11
From: sally
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
"bfd" <bfd853@comcast.net > wrote in news:h5SdnV1utJyrefzbnZ2dnUVZ_ompnZ2d@comcast.com: > Do you have any bike shops near you? My LBS sell Grade 25 bearings for > $0.05 each! If you must mail order, check out www.biketoolsetc.com Postage on small items usually kills the price difference vs. your local bike shop.
|
| |
Date: 02 Jun 2007 21:21:06
From: limeylew@gmail.com
Subject: Re: Good Online source for loose bearings?
|
On Jun 2, 4:16 pm, RS <r_schil...@comcast.net > wrote: > I need grade 25 1/4" bearings, 50 or 100. What's a good place to > order from? thanks Thia should do it for you. http://www.mcmaster.com/ type in this part number 9528K15 Lewis. *****
|
|